
It Should Have Been You
It Should Have Been You is a psychological thriller about a private message sent to a neighbourhood WhatsApp group, the rumours and threats that follow, and a murder linked to a matching address. The listing describes a suburban suspense story, while customer feedback highlights twists and brisk pacing alongside mixed opinions about character depth.
At a glance
- The premise centres on an accidentally shared neighbourhood message and the fallout that turns toward threats and murder.
- Customer feedback describes a fast-moving read with twists and shorter chapters.
Reference price: $26.00
Price checked: Nov 19, 2026
View offerAhead of Black FridayExplore the selectionOften bought together
Pros and cons
Pros
- The listed 384-page length gives buyers a clear idea of the book's print extent.
- Customer feedback cites engaging suspense, twists and momentum as appealing elements.
Cons
- Readers' views on character depth are mixed, which may matter to buyers who prioritise strongly developed characters.
Technical specifications
8 specifications| Publisher | Doubleday Canada |
|---|---|
| Publication date | Dec 16 2025 |
| Language | English |
| Print length | 384 pages |
| ISBN-10 | 0385699492 |
| ISBN-13 | 978-0385699495 |
| Dimensions | 13.97 x 2.54 x 20.96 cm |
|---|---|
| Weight listed | 340 g |
Who is it for?
A good fit for
- Readers looking for a contemporary neighbourhood-set psychological thriller involving rumours and a murder mystery.
- Thriller readers who value twists and brisk pacing, as described in customer feedback.
Less suited to
- Readers who need consistently detailed character development, since feedback on character depth is mixed.
Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
40% 40% - 4 stars
36% 36% - 3 stars
19% 19% - 2 stars
4% 4% - 1 star
1% 1%
Customer feedback highlights an engaging, suspenseful read, with twists, brisk pacing and shorter chapters noted as reasons the story keeps moving. In practical terms, those reported strengths suit thriller readers looking for momentum, while mixed reactions to character depth may matter more to readers who want richly developed characters. These are reader perceptions, not guarantees about an individual reading experience.
Positive themes
- Customers describe the book as engaging and suspenseful, with twists and brisk pacing.
- Readers mention shorter chapters and easy readability as helping maintain momentum.
Mixed feedback
- Opinions on character depth vary, with some readers finding the characters interesting and others feeling disconnected from them.
Frequently asked questions
What is It Should Have Been You about?
The listing describes a message meant for a sister that is accidentally sent to a local WhatsApp group, followed by spreading rumours, a death threat and a murder connected to a matching address.
How long is the book?
The listing gives a print length of 384 pages.
What do customers say about the pacing and characters?
Feedback describes the story as engaging and fast-paced, with twists and shorter chapters. Opinions on character depth vary.
Alternative options

Brain Damage
$17.39

The Witch (Deluxe Edition)
$25.99

A Man With One of Those Faces
$16.99

If Walls Could Talk: The Dunmara Series - Book 1
$9.99

The Library (The Library Trilogy Book 1)
$9.99

Darkness Awaits You
$19.09

Kentucky Blood: A Gripping Southern Gothic Psychological Thriller Series (The Kentucky Blood Series Book 1)
$2.99

The Library
$16.99

The Last Nazi: A Joe Johnson Thriller
$23.99

My First Library: Boxset of 10 Board Books for Kids
$22.42

























