Loonie PerksDeals for Canada
Search
Product guide

If He Had Been with Me — YA Romance

If He Had Been with Me is a young adult romance about former childhood friends Autumn and Finn, who grow apart while still wondering whether they belong together. The listing describes a story of love, regret and the consequences of paths not taken, with a major change approaching in August.

At a glance

  • Centres on Autumn and Finn, former inseparable friends who now avoid each other but continue to question what might have been.
  • The listing positions it as contemporary YA romance with emotional themes of love, regret and changing relationships.
  • A 400-page English-language reissue from Sourcebooks.
Price
$14.03Save 15%

Reference price: $16.50

Price checked: Nov 18, 2026

View offerAhead of Black FridayExplore the selection

Often bought together

Pros and cons

Pros

  • The friendship-to-romance premise gives the story a clear emotional tension, with both characters navigating changed lives and lingering feelings.
  • Its substantial 400-page length may suit readers looking for an extended character-focused YA story.

Cons

  • Some readers report that the pacing drags through much of the story and slows again near the end.

Technical specifications

11 specifications
Publication
PublisherSourcebooks
Publication dateNov. 1 2019
EditionReissue
LanguageEnglish
Print length400 pages
Suggested reading ageCustomer suggested age: 16 years and up
Grade level8 - 12
Identifiers
ISBN-101728205484
ISBN-13978-1728205489
Dimensions and installation
Dimensions14 x 2.5 x 21 cm
Weight listed399 g

What to know before buying

  • The listed suggested reading age is 16 years and up, while the listed grade level is 8 - 12. Customer feedback is divided on whether the book feels age-appropriate, so readers may want to consider both the age guidance and the intended reader's preferences.

Who is it for?

A good fit for

  • Readers looking for contemporary young adult romance centred on old friends and unresolved feelings.
  • Fans of emotionally focused coming-of-age stories about relationships and regret.
  • Readers comfortable with a long novel whose pacing and ending may not work for everyone.

Less suited to

  • Readers who prefer consistently brisk pacing or a straightforwardly satisfying ending.
  • Readers seeking a light romance without emotionally weighty themes.

Customer reviews on Amazon

4.1 / 5 · 65,482 ratings
  • 5 stars45%45%
  • 4 stars29%29%
  • 3 stars19%19%
  • 2 stars5%5%
  • 1 star2%2%

Customer feedback is positive about the content and engagement, with readers describing the story as interesting and easy to get drawn into. The reported concerns are its slow stretches and slower ending, while reactions to the ending, emotional impact, character relationships and age fit vary. For readers choosing a long YA romance, these differing responses suggest that the premise may appeal more consistently than the pacing or resolution. The overall rating distribution is mixed rather than uniformly positive.

Positive themes

  • Readers describe the content as interesting and the story as engaging.
  • Some customers report that the book feels worth buying.

Negative themes

  • Some readers say the pacing drags through about three-quarters of the story and slows near the end.

Mixed feedback

  • Readers disagree about the ending, emotional effect and whether they connect with the main characters' relationships.
  • Feedback differs on whether the book's age range suits a given reader.

Frequently asked questions

What is If He Had Been with Me about?

Autumn and Finn were once inseparable, but their lives have diverged. The story follows their lingering feelings and Autumn's thoughts about how things might have gone differently.

How long is the book?

The listing gives a print length of 400 pages.

What age is the book suggested for?

The listing says the customer-suggested reading age is 16 years and up and gives a grade level of 8 - 12. Feedback varies on whether it feels suitable for younger or older readers.

What do readers say about the pacing and ending?

Customer feedback includes criticism that the story drags for much of its length and slows near the end. Reactions to the ending are mixed.

Alternative options

Products with discounts that might interest you

4.7
The Tale of Despereaux by Kate DiCamillo, 272-page reprint
The Tale of Despereaux by Kate DiCamillo, 272-page reprint

C$13.99

C$10.19

-27%
-27%
Product details in Markdown