1 / 7Too Faced Killer Liner 36 Hour Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil, 1.2 g
Too Faced Killer Liner is a gel eyeliner pencil advertised for up to 36-hour wear, with a smooth formula intended to allow blending before it sets. Its waterproof and transfer-resistant claims may appeal to longer-wear looks, but customer feedback is mixed on longevity and smudge resistance.
At a glance
- The gel pencil is advertised with a 36-hour wear claim and waterproof, transfer-resistant, non-flaking properties.
- The manufacturer says the formula allows blending before it dries down.
- A dual-blade or metal sharpener is recommended for sharpening.
Reference price: $37.00
Price checked: Nov 20, 2026
View offerBlack Friday weekExplore the selectionPros and cons
Pros
- Smooth application and colour are highlighted positively in customer feedback.
- The pencil format supports sharp, smoky or lash-definition looks, according to the listing.
- The suggested sharpening tools are clearly specified.
Cons
- Sharpening is a reported customer pain point, so this pencil may be less convenient than a retractable liner.
- Customer feedback is mixed on wear time and smudge resistance, despite the listing's long-wear claims.
Technical specifications
10 specifications| Brand | Too Faced |
|---|---|
| Product type | Gel eyeliner pencil |
| Item model number | 3CFT010000 |
| Net weight | 1.2g |
| Cruelty-free claim | Cruelty Free |
| Claimed wear time | 36 hour wear gel formula |
|---|---|
| Wear claims | Waterproof, transfer resistant, and non-flaking |
| Application | Smooth formula for easy application |
| Sharpening | Sharpen with dual-blade or metal sharpener |
| Dimensions listed | 5.5 x 1.4 x 14.2 cm; 16 g |
|---|
What to know before buying
- The 36-hour wear, waterproof, transfer-resistant and non-flaking statements are manufacturer claims, not independently verified performance. Customer feedback is mixed on longevity and smudge resistance, so results may not match the stated wear claims. The listing recommends a dual-blade or metal sharpener.
Who is it for?
A good fit for
- Makeup users who prefer a gel pencil that can be blended before setting.
- Buyers seeking a liner for winged, smoky or simple lash-definition looks.
Less suited to
- Anyone wanting a retractable liner or who prefers not to sharpen pencils.
- Buyers who need customer feedback to consistently confirm long wear or smudge resistance.

Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
70% 70% - 4 stars
10% 10% - 3 stars
9% 9% - 2 stars
3% 3% - 1 star
8% 8%
Customer feedback highlights colour and smooth application as strengths, while sharpening is a reported frustration. Opinions are mixed on longevity, smudge resistance and value. That matters for a pencil promoted for 36-hour, waterproof wear, since those claims are not consistently reflected in reported experiences. Aggregate ratings lean positive overall, but the distribution also includes lower ratings and does not explain individual reasons.
Positive themes
- Customers report attractive colour.
- Customers describe application as smooth.
Negative themes
- Some customer feedback expresses dissatisfaction with sharpening.
Mixed feedback
- Customer opinions vary on longevity, smudge resistance and value for money.
Frequently asked questions
How long does the liner claim to last?
The listing describes a 36-hour wear gel formula. That is a manufacturer claim, and customer feedback is mixed on longevity.
What sharpener should I use?
The listing recommends a dual-blade or metal sharpener. Customers also report dissatisfaction with the sharpening process.
Can it be blended after application?
The manufacturer says it has play time for blending and smoky effects before it dries down.

Alternative options

wet n wild Mega Last Breakup Proof Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner, Black, Quick Drying Retractable Gel Eyeliner, Smudge Resistant, Long Lasting 16 Hour Wear, Ultra Fine Brush Tip Pen
$4.97

12PCS White Eyeliner Pencil Set,High Pigmented Smudge-Proof White Eye Liner Pencils,Long lasting Waterproofing Eyeliner Pencil,Smooth Soft Eye Liner Pen for Makeup
$9.98

stila Stay All Day® ArtiStix Graphic Liner - Flamenco | Bold Graphic Eyeliner, Waterproof Smudge-Proof, Vivid Long-Lasting Color All-Day Wear, Doubles As An Eyeshadow, Cruelty-Free
$25.78

2Pcs Black Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Pencil for Daily & Halloween | Smudge-proof, creamy smooth glide, long-lasting, gothic & party look, versatile for shadow & brow, easy removal
$11.98

Black Eyeliner - Waterproof Gel Eyeliner | Smudge-Proof Eye Liner Gel for The | High Pigment Eye Makeup Stick | Swing Eye Makeup for Perfect Contours (Black, 1PC) Littryee
$11.49

Gel Eyeliner - Smudge Proof Eyeliner Pencil - Waterproof Eyeliner Gel Stick - Matte Eyeliner Pencil - Makeup Eye-Liners for Women Girls (Black) Littryee
$12.09

Kuuleyn Black Gel Eyeliners Pencil,Pencil Eyeliners,Black Face Paint Sticks,Makeup Cosmetic Eyeliners Stick Pencil Long lasting NOn smudge Matte Eye Liner Pen Gel
$14.10

Filorga Optim-Eyes Intensive 3-in-1 Eye Contour Cream, 15ml | Eye Contour Cream - Suitable For Senstive Eyes - With Peptides & Hyaluronic Acids - Fresh & Creamy Hydrating Texture
$60.80

haruharu wonder Black Rice Probiotics Barrier Essence, 120 mL | Milky Toner, Deep Hydration, Glass Skin, Non-Comedogenic, Skin Barrier, Ceramide & Panthenol, Vegan, Korean Skin Care
$24.98

haruharu wonder Black Rice 5 Ceramide Barrier Moisturizing Cream, 50 mL | Daily Barrier, Lasting Hydration, for All Skin Types, Soothing & Nourishing, Ceramide, Cruelty Free, Vegan, Korean Skin Care
$22.88

haruharu wonder Black Rice Probiotics 2% NAD+ Serum Mist, 80 mL | Hydrating & Plumping, Ultra-Fine Mist, Glass Skin, Barrier Support, Sensitive Skin, Ceramide, Vegan, Korean Skin Care
$22.00

APRÉS Base Gelcoat X 15ml | HEMA & TPO-Free Rubber Base Scratch Resistant Gel Nail Polish Soak Off Base Coat
$15.98























