
Never Keep: Sins of the Zodiac, Book 1
Book: Never Keep by Caroline Peckham and Susanne Valenti opens the Sins of the Zodiac series with a dark romantasy of elemental magic, enemies-to-lovers tension and a war college setting. The listing describes Fae conscripts sent to a fortress where their magic is awakened, alongside dragons, vampires and werewolves.
At a glance
- Book 1 in the Sins of the Zodiac series, set in the same world as Zodiac Academy.
- Dark romantasy built around Fae, elemental powers and a war college.
- The publisher describes enemies-to-lovers romance, morally grey characters and fated mates.
- The story centres on conscripts sent to Never Keep, where their magic can be awakened.
Reference price: $40.99
Price checked: Nov 18, 2026
View offerAhead of Black FridayExplore the selectionOften bought together
Pros and cons
Pros
- The series premise combines a magical training setting with a wider conflict among elemental nations.
- The listing identifies several romantasy elements for readers seeking Fae, vampires, dragons and werewolves.
- At 736 pages, this is a substantial first instalment for readers ready for a long fantasy novel.
Cons
- The 736-page length may be a commitment for readers who prefer shorter novels.
- The listing flags a slow start and dragging midsection as concerns reflected in customer feedback.
Technical specifications
9 specifications| Series | Sins of the Zodiac |
|---|---|
| Publisher | King's Hollow |
| Publication date | Oct. 15 2024 |
| Language | English |
| Print length | 736 pages |
| ISBN-10 | 1916926274 |
| ISBN-13 | 978-1916926271 |
| Weight listed | 635 g |
|---|---|
| Dimensions | 15.24 x 5.33 x 22.86 cm |
What to know before buying
- Customer feedback describes a divided pacing experience, including a slow start and a midsection that can drag. Some readers also say the story can be hard to follow, so consider this if you prefer tightly paced, straightforward fantasy.
Who is it for?
A good fit for
- Romantasy readers looking for a dark, lengthy series opener with Fae and elemental magic.
- Readers drawn to enemies-to-lovers tension, morally grey characters and war-college settings.
- Fans of interconnected fantasy worlds who are interested in a story set in the Zodiac Academy world.
Less suited to
- Readers who want a short book or consistently brisk pacing.
- Readers seeking a light, low-conflict romance or an uncomplicated plot.
Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
42% 42% - 4 stars
41% 41% - 3 stars
15% 15% - 2 stars
1% 1% - 1 star
1% 1%
Customer feedback highlights an enjoyable story, plot twists, memorable characters and strong emotional involvement, with some readers calling it an effective series opener. Others report a slow start, a dragging middle and moments that are hard to follow or lose their interest. This split is relevant for a 736-page fantasy novel, where pacing and readability can make a substantial difference to the reading experience. Aggregate ratings lean positive overall, but do not resolve those differences in individual responses.
Positive themes
- Readers describe the book as enjoyable, with plot twists and characters they feel connected to.
- Some readers say the story is emotionally affecting and works well as the start of a series.
Negative themes
- Some readers report a slow start and a midsection that drags.
- Some readers find the story difficult to follow or say they become bored at times.
Mixed feedback
- Customer feedback praises the engaging story while also describing uneven pacing and readability.
Frequently asked questions
Is Never Keep part of a series?
Yes. It is Book 1 in the Sins of the Zodiac series and is set in the same world as Zodiac Academy.
What kind of story is Never Keep?
The listing describes a dark romantasy featuring Fae, elemental powers, a war college, enemies-to-lovers tension and a conflict among nations.
How long is the book?
The listed print length is 736 pages.
What do customers say about the pacing?
Customer feedback is mixed on pacing. Some describe an engaging story with plot twists, while others mention a slow start and a midsection that drags.
Alternative options

Forbidden Astrology: Beginner's Practical Guide To The Zodiac + Your Personal Annual Forecast Report Included (Same one my private clients pay 429 for)
$28.53

The Score
$24.64

Dark Waves: Mind Hackers Series, Novella
$17.77

Her Creation (Deluxe Edition)
$28.41

Lady of Darkness (Lady of Darkness Series Book 1)
$7.01

Runebreaker
$45.45

The Ice Beyond (Deluxe Edition)
$37.20

Forbidden Astrology: Beginner's Practical Guide To The Zodiac + Your Personal Annual Forecast Report Included (Same one my private clients pay 429 for)
$6.99

Dark Waves: Mind Hackers Series, Novella
$5.54

Chief Inspiration Officer: How to Lead the Team Everyone Wants to Be On
$29.88

























