
Missing Molly: A Novel by Natalie Barelli
Novel: Missing Molly is Natalie Barelli’s psychological thriller about Rachel Holloway, a woman whose quiet London life is threatened when a true-crime podcast revisits the disappearance of Molly Forster. Rachel knows what happened because she is Molly, and new evidence suggests the wrong man was convicted.
At a glance
- A cold case returns to public attention through a newspaper’s true-crime podcast.
- Rachel’s concealed identity links her directly to the missing girl, Molly Forster.
- New evidence points to a wrongful conviction and a killer who remains free.
Often bought together
Pros and cons
Pros
- The central identity reveal gives the cold-case investigation a personal stake.
- Its podcast and newspaper premise ties public scrutiny to Rachel’s attempt to stay hidden.
Technical specifications
9 specifications| Title | Missing Molly: A Novel |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Sourcebooks |
| Publication date | Oct. 20 2026 |
| Language | English |
| Print length | 336 pages |
| ISBN-10 | 146424751X |
| ISBN-13 | 978-1464247514 |
| Dimensions | 13.97 x 2.13 x 20.96 cm |
|---|---|
| Weight listed | 295 g |
Who is it for?
A good fit for
- Readers looking for a psychological thriller built around a cold case and concealed identity.
- Those interested in crime reporting, wrongful convictions and threats to a protagonist’s rebuilt life.
Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
47% 47% - 4 stars
35% 35% - 3 stars
13% 13% - 2 stars
3% 3% - 1 star
2% 2%
Customer feedback describes the story as suspenseful and engrossing, with readers praising its plot and ability to hold attention. Pacing opinions differ, including reports that it starts slowly, and character development draws mixed reactions. Those differences may matter to readers seeking an immediately fast-moving thriller or especially consistent character work. The aggregate rating is positive overall, but ratings alone do not explain individual opinions.
Positive themes
- Readers report an interesting, engaging plot and strong suspense.
Mixed feedback
- Feedback is divided on pacing, including whether the story begins slowly.
- Character development receives mixed reactions, particularly around the main character.
Frequently asked questions
What is Missing Molly about?
Rachel Holloway’s local newspaper launches a true-crime podcast about Molly Forster, a girl who disappeared after her family was murdered. Rachel knows Molly’s fate because she is Molly, and the renewed attention puts her in danger.
Who wrote Missing Molly?
The listing identifies Natalie Barelli as the author.
How long is the book?
The listing gives a print length of 336 pages.
Alternative options

The Boyfriend
$13.59

The Perfect Son
$22.94

When They Find Me: A Novel
$28.99

Do Not Disturb
$19.00

Brain Damage
$17.39

The Fifth Juror
$19.79

The Coworker
$20.38

The Locked Door
$22.94

























