# Oatey 43538 4-Inch Closet Flange Replacement

The Oatey 43538 closet flange replacement is listed for replacing a broken cast-iron closet flange. Its compression gasket and three stainless-steel bolts are intended to secure it to existing cast-iron piping, with claimed riser adjustment of up to 3 inches.

- [Original product page](https://loonieperks.com/product/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)
- [View offer](https://loonieperks.com/visit/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)
- Market: CA
- Language: en-CA
- Currency: CAD
- Brand: Oatey
- Model: 43538
- Category: [Tools & Garden &gt; Electrical & Plumbing](https://loonieperks.com/tools-and-garden/electrical-and-plumbing)
- Price: 36.10 CAD
- Previous price: 62.89 CAD
- Discount: 43%
- Price checked: 2026-11-20T06:36:44.841Z
- Rating: 4.5 / 5
- Reviews: 636

Prices and deal status are the latest recorded data, not a guarantee of availability. Confirm the price and availability with the store.

## At a glance

- Designed to replace broken or corroded cast-iron closet flanges without tearing up the existing floor, according to the listing.
- A rubber compression gasket and three stainless-steel bolts are specified for securing the flange to existing piping.
- The listing claims up to 3 inches of riser adjustment and tool-free installation.

## Pros

- Compression joining is designed to accommodate some variation in riser position, with up to 3 inches of adjustment claimed.
- The stated gasket-and-bolt arrangement is intended for use with many types of cast-iron piping.

## Specifications

### Identity
- Brand: Oatey
- Model: 43538
### Dimensions and installation
- Dimensions listed: 10.2 x 17.8 x 17.8 centimetres
- Weight listed: 318 g
### Materials and protection
- Material listed: Cast Iron
### Fit and construction
- Nominal size: 4 Inch
- Thread size: 4 inch
- Thread type: NPT
- Connector type: Flange
- Colour: Black
- Pieces: 1

## Before you buy

- The title calls the product black ABS, while the specifications list cast iron and the feature text calls it durable plastic. Material details are contradictory, so confirm the actual construction before purchase, especially if material is important for the repair. The 4-inch size and NPT thread listing do not establish compatibility with every existing pipe or installation.

## In the box

- Closet flange (Included)

## A good fit for

- Replacing a damaged cast-iron closet flange where the existing floor is to remain in place.
- Buyers matching a 4-inch flange to existing cast-iron piping and able to confirm fit at the installation.

## Less suited to

- Buyers who need a confirmed ABS or confirmed cast-iron part without first resolving the material discrepancy.
- Installations where pipe size, condition or connection requirements have not been checked against the listed 4-inch size and NPT thread.

## Customer feedback

Customer feedback describes the fitting as useful for connecting to cast pipes, with positive reports about fit, quality and installation. Experiences are mixed on ease of use and value, so the claimed tool-free installation should not be taken as a guarantee that every repair will be straightforward. The feedback suits its intended role as a cast-pipe flange replacement, but does not resolve the listing's contradictory material descriptions.
- Positive themes: Customers describe the fitting as working well and report positive impressions of its fit and quality.
- Positive themes: Feedback reports that it can serve as a solution for connecting to cast pipes.
- Mixed feedback: Customer opinions vary on ease of use and value for money.

### Rating distribution

- 5 stars: 76%
- 4 stars: 12%
- 3 stars: 5%
- 2 stars: 2%
- 1 star: 5%

## Frequently asked questions

### What is the Oatey 43538 intended to replace?
The listing describes it as a replacement for a broken or corroded cast-iron closet flange.
### How much riser adjustment is claimed?
The listing claims the compression joint allows up to 3 inches of adjustment to the riser.
### What material is the flange?
The listing conflicts: the title says black ABS, while its details list cast iron and a feature calls the construction plastic. Confirm the material before ordering.
### Does it fit every 4-inch pipe?
The listing gives a 4-inch size and NPT thread type, but these details alone do not confirm compatibility with every existing pipe. Check the connection and installation requirements.

## Alternative options

- [One N Done 400DS Toilet Flange Repair Kit – Deepest Seal – Diamond Saw \| Universal fit, wax-free toilet seal, toilet wax ring replacement, broken toilet flange repair, locking toilet caps](https://loonieperks.com/visit/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)
- [Elastic Wax Ring Toilet Flange Repair Kit for 3" & 4" Pipes, Universal Fit \| Premium Toilet Seal and Gasket Replacement, For DIY Bathroom Repairs Solution, Mess-free Installation Without Sticky Residue](https://loonieperks.com/visit/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)
- [BlueStars RV Toilet Seal 3" Socket Floor Flange Kit for Dometic 300 310 \| Replaces 385345892 Flange 385311658 Flush Ball Seal and 385311652 Base Seal RV Toilet Replacement Parts](https://loonieperks.com/visit/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)
- [3853458923 SE345892 3 Inch RV Toilet Flange Seal Kit for Dometic Thetfor 300 310 320 Toilets - Includes 3385311658, 385311652 Flush Seal](https://loonieperks.com/visit/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)
- [Toilet Flange Repair Kit with Wax Ring for 3-4 Inch Waste Lines \| 0.92'' Thick, Leaking Toilet Repair, Floor-Mounted Toilet Installation, Complete Hardware Replacement](https://loonieperks.com/visit/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)
- [385345892 RV Toilet 3" Socket Floor Flange fit for Dometic Toilets and Thetfor Toilets](https://loonieperks.com/visit/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)
- [EATAKWARD 385311658 3 Inch RV Toilet Flange Seal Kit, Replacement for RV Toilet Seal and Socket, Replaces 385311652 385345892 SE345892](https://loonieperks.com/visit/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)
- [boeemi TF02-RI Toilet Flange Repair Kit & Elastic Wax Ring, Universal Fit \| Watertight odor proof seal, Fits standard floor toilets, Elastic wax ring with horn, Straightforward DIY repair kit](https://loonieperks.com/visit/boeemi-tf02-ri-toilet-flange-repair-kit)
- [BLEKOO PVC Pipe Reamer 1-1/2 Inch, Fit Into Standard 1/2" Drills \| Features Universal 1/2-inch Drill Compatibility, 3/8" Hex Spindle, Perfect for Schedule 40 PVC/CPVC/ABS Pipes](https://loonieperks.com/visit/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)
- [Hibbent Toilet Wax Ring Kit, Toilet Bowl Wax Ring with Brass Closet Bolts \| Universal Bolts, Caps, PE Flange and Extra Retainers, Thick Wax Ring Gasket for Toilet Bowl- Gas, Odor and Watertight Seal](https://loonieperks.com/visit/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)
- [VIVOSUN D4 4 Inch 195 CFM Inline Duct Ventilation Fan HVAC Vent Blower for Hydroponics Grow Tent](https://loonieperks.com/visit/vivosun-d4-4-inch-inline-duct-fan)
- [MAX DISPOSER Garbage Disposal 3/4 HP for Kitchen Sink Quiet with Stopper Power Cord, Easy Install, Continuous Feed Food Waste Disposer Stainless Steel Grind 0.75 Horsepower AC Motor Unit \(MAX-4\)](https://loonieperks.com/visit/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)

## Add-ons

- [LASCO Toilet Bowl Extra Thick Wax Ring with Brass Bolts Reinforced Urethane Core and Polyethylene Flange - 516545, Yellow](https://loonieperks.com/visit/lasco-04-3314-extra-thick-toilet-wax-ring)
- [Fluidmaster 7530 Universal Better Than Wax Toilet Seal, Wax-Free Toilet Bowl Gasket Fits Any Drain](https://loonieperks.com/visit/oatey-43538-4-inch-closet-flange-replacement)

## Images

![Oatey 43538 4-Inch Closet Flange Replacement — 1](https://loonieperks.com/i/2ivAMFcMVwlKLjh87u_HnzQJ_n3SLNbUmbSgqUjngyMmREChI_3pgggDYnJwk6BfEfxvHimSB4VB3JUSoa5TNorFOQYR4EiLLTLNQ7MvaM_iUCh6bM9omn6R.jpg)

![Oatey 43538 4-Inch Closet Flange Replacement — 2](https://loonieperks.com/i/0r6F495p7DaKzgjqL4HZHgzUbSM_IQPgiXEwMqP0aQ_ahWCzbJr1akfRWnwCaggGEQMaw5WWe8X99V_AxFJHXGe9z3znsxK-gLUK4cGpuXzuElEn0LIvGP27.jpg)

![Oatey 43538 4-Inch Closet Flange Replacement — 3](https://loonieperks.com/i/NhaCpiZF6TdFW3eBVkf1kXTvlWhpEaXhgq8yJILuOPdKydKi7SGqKZe_bK5939mQdfaR7Or15CYvLjNTLFCOSIXO2U7qcjig4Sl_IO3C9m6v6ULDEasp33SD.jpg)

![Oatey 43538 4-Inch Closet Flange Replacement — 4](https://loonieperks.com/i/LR0xriJbxV5H2AkA0MQTF3tVvFGtQqmT60f6KHbqF8hNObOLSsqgn4q1kPy0IgLKZmGAePeLJejoQhqeQjo-ZWuqK0vToPs1F_9e8zzh9DlHfAHkdXnNvbm9.jpg)

![Oatey 43538 4-Inch Closet Flange Replacement — 5](https://loonieperks.com/i/rQ4EwFmRY6mUU8NtTOzxSRp6ugg0we6TEY5d0JlqB2aoXuKHqrpjOfdQ02KnDEX1D3tSGnrPbw_UNZ0DGuL4kTc8P984NkM6LrU5_8p0GsNbib5pWmOEE3Mg.jpg)

![Oatey 43538 4-Inch Closet Flange Replacement — 6](https://loonieperks.com/i/T1PO5g0pFLsZDoUL4oDVi1MOnJ3ho_mMZ5cP556ZkxIoqTSEzoVE9ZLPoCXNoahNMUISzMqM0zimx6g_L2brgG187mMO-IrEoOesZX8U6lbdqYPDORu-_FVI.jpg)
