1 / 2If We Were Villains: A Novel
If We Were Villains is a novel about seven Shakespearean actors whose rivalry turns violent during their final year at a secluded conservatory. The story follows Oliver, released from jail a decade later, as he recounts events to the detective who arrested him.
At a glance
- A secluded classical conservatory setting centres the story on seven young Shakespearean actors.
- A decade after Oliver's release from jail, his account revisits a violent incident on opening night.
- The plot pairs rivalry and friendship with questions of innocence, truth and performance.
Often bought together
Pros and cons
Pros
- The actor-and-conservatory premise ties Shakespearean roles to the characters' rivalries offstage.
- The framing conversation between Oliver and the detective gives the story a retrospective mystery structure.
- Customer feedback describes the writing as engaging and emotionally affecting.
Technical specifications
9 specifications| Publisher | Flatiron Books |
|---|---|
| Publication date | April 17 2018 |
| Edition | Reprint |
| Language | English |
| Print length | 368 pages |
| Dimensions | 14.05 x 2.34 x 21.03 cm |
|---|---|
| Weight listed | 390 g |
| ISBN-10 | 1250095298 |
|---|---|
| ISBN-13 | 978-1250095299 |
What to know before buying
- Customer feedback is mixed on the storyline and character likability, and some readers report pages tearing or peeling apart. These are reader-reported experiences, not confirmed defects.
Who is it for?
A good fit for
- Readers interested in Shakespeare, theatre settings and character-driven mysteries.
- Readers who enjoy stories about friendship, ambition and suspicion after a violent event.
Less suited to
- Readers looking for a light plot with consistently likeable characters, as feedback on the story and cast is divided.

Customer reviews on Amazon
- 5 stars
59% 59% - 4 stars
22% 22% - 3 stars
15% 15% - 2 stars
3% 3% - 1 star
1% 1%
Customer feedback describes the book as engaging, emotionally affecting and quick to read, with readers praising its writing and calling it a favourite. Reactions are not uniform: opinions differ on the storyline and whether the main characters are appealing, and some readers report pages tearing or peeling apart. For readers drawn to the listed theatre setting and suspense premise, the positive reports about pace and emotional impact may appeal, while the mixed story and character responses are worth weighing. Page concerns are reader reports, not independently confirmed.
Positive themes
- Readers describe the book as engaging and emotionally affecting.
- Some readers praise the writing and say the book moves quickly.
Mixed feedback
- Opinions differ on whether the storyline is compelling.
- Character responses vary, including whether the main characters are likeable.
- Some readers report pages tearing or peeling apart, while others do not mention that issue.
Frequently asked questions
What is If We Were Villains about?
It follows seven Shakespearean actors at a secluded conservatory, where rivalries escalate into real violence. A decade later, Oliver tells the detective who put him in jail what happened.
How long is this edition?
The listing gives a print length of 368 pages.
What do readers report about the book?
Feedback highlights engaging writing and an emotional reading experience, while opinions vary on the storyline and character likability. Some readers also describe page durability problems.
Alternative options

The Witch (Deluxe Edition)
$25.99

Maria's Child
$20.37

The Divine Comedy
$17.99

Ward D
$22.94

The Fifth Juror
$19.79

Kentucky Blood: A Gripping Southern Gothic Psychological Thriller Series (The Kentucky Blood Series Book 1)
$2.99

The Correspondent: A Novel
$24.30

The Dawning Kind: A First Contact Sci-Fi Novel of Human Evolution and Alien Transformation
$8.54

My First Library: Boxset of 10 Board Books for Kids
$22.42

























